Technical, Equipment and Maintenance
Here’s where we take a look at some of the equipment we use and what we think of it. We’ll also add some thoughts on what we learn about sailing Skylark, what work we have done and any improvements we make.
Scroll down the page or clink on the links below to go to a specific topic.
Our tender: Rebel Superyacht 330
We spent a lot of time looking for the right dinghy. Keeping weight down was a consideration alongside having something that could carry decent loads and be easy to drive and manoeuvre, hence the idea of a floating console with a wheel and throttle arrangement. Highfield seem to have cornered much of the market, but were a bit heavier and more expensive than the Rebel. We found Rebel Leisure through an internet search and had a long chat with Graeme at Rebel RIBS before buying the tender through NJC Auto Marine in Poole, UK. NJC’s owner, Neil, was tremendous and put a package for the tender, Tohastsu 20hp outboard, cover and trailer together.
We have been delighted with the Rebel. It looks smart, with the tan seats and dark blue sides, An aluminium hull and hypalon tubing make it rigid, strong, relatively light and so easy to drive. Add nice touches like two boarding steps, lockable storage, electric bilge pump and lights for night use and it’s a definite recommend!
The arrangement for tender stowage on the Neels is unusual. Rather than davits, the topping lift is used as a hoist to raise and lower the dinghy onto chocks set into the central hull. (For those wondering, while the topping lift is loose, the boom is held up by the lazy jacks which have been strengthened specifically to take the weight of the boom and mainsail.) It takes a bit of getting used to, but overall works well and keeps the stern and transom clear.
Estarli e20.7 Pro e-bikes
These have been a great purchase! We can explore further afield, use the really handy racks for panniers or smaller shopping loads, and they are comfortable enough to use for several hours without ‘numb bum’ setting in. They work on the ‘assisted pedalling’ principle; you have to pedal to get the electric assistance, which has 5 levels and can be turned off completely if you want an extra work out. The motors have sufficient oomph to make light work of steep, twisty roads up to hilltop villages and give a welcome boost to tired riders at the end of a long day. The bikes allow us to visit places that we’d otherwise have to hire a car to see, and we get some decent exercise into the bargain! We tend to use the lowest electric assist we can which means our range is pretty good; we can cover 40 miles on a single charge, more if we turn assist off on the flat and downhill.
At 18kg they are not the lightest e-bikes around, but they are easily manageable even using the tender. They fold up small enough to stow away onboard or take into a café, have built in locks (although we also have a sturdy chain and padlock) and are made in Great Britain. The 20 inch wheels give great stability, manoeuvrability and comfort and we invested in padded seats for extra support. A super addition to our cruising life.
Rocna Vulcan anchor
Why we wanted to upgrade the anchor. One of the first items we upgraded on Skylark was the anchor. We knew our preference was to spend the vast majority of our time at anchor rather than in marinas, exploring lesser known bays and having that wonderful feeling of being a little more connected to nature and our surroundings. The Neel factory-supplied Kobra 25kg anchor is up to the job ok, and we know several Neel 51 owners who have been very happy with it and have kept it. But for added security and, more importantly, the reassurance heavier, modern ground tackle gives us, we decided to upgrade.
What models did we consider? After much research, and looking at all manner of online video comparisons and tests, we narrowed it to two contenders; Ultra Marine and Rocna Vulcan. We knew the Mk 1 Rocna with its distinctive roll bar would not fit in the bowsprit, hence looking at Rocna’s Vulcan range. They are both reassuringly pricey; Ultra only make their products in stainless steel, whereas Rocna have both stainless and galvanised versions. Helpfully, both companies can provide a life-size template of their anchors, so we printed these out and then transcribed them onto stiffer cardboard to test.
Which one did we choose? The final decision on which one to go for ended up being easy. It turned out the Ultra simply didn't fit through our bow roller due to its slightly angled shank, so Rocna Vulcan it was. What an excellent idea those templates are! We went for the 45kg galvanised model - one size up on the Rocna chart recommendations to take account of the additional windage of a multihull, despite it being a lighter boat than an equivalent mono. A new anchor shackle, with an 11 ton breaking strain, completed the purchase. We checked our chain too - 12mm galvanised - and all was well.
Our verdict; was it a worthwhile upgrade? A resounding ‘yes’! The Rocna has not disappointed in over 100 nights on the hook in our first season alone. It digs into sand, mud and light weed beautifully, the heavy tip burying deep into the seabed, but on thick seaweed and shingle/rock it can take a couple of goes to get a reliable hold. Once set it has never dragged, including in 50 knot gales and over 2 metre swells, which unsurprisingly were miserably uncomfortable! We are generous with the scope, preferring 4-to-1 and often more if there is swinging room.
As an aside, we are just as conscious of swell as of wind when choosing an anchorage. Skylark will sit head to wind quite nicely, but in light winds, say less than 5 knots, she’ll tend to sit beam onto any swell which Nick finds particularly irritating. A second stern anchor (we have a 20kg Danforth kedge) can help, but does add time and complexity when we are just the two of us.
In our first season we rigged a single snubber to a central cleat to help take shock loading. Having had the extra forward ama cleats fitted during our March 26 maintenance, we also invested in a dual bridal system which we had custom made by Jimmy Green Marine in Beer, Devon. We have found the bridle slightly reduces the yawing motion of Skylark and perhaps aligns us more accurately with yachts anchored nearby, but it does take an extra few minutes to set and retrieve. To attach the bridle to the chain we use a soft shackle rather than the metal grab we have on the single snubber.
Yanmar Generator
Perhaps my least favoured piece of equipment onboard.
A strong statement, for sure, but a reflection of the trouble we have experienced with it. When we purchased Skylark, the generator, a Yanmar GSi 12S, had just 37 hours of running time. Barely run in. We tested it during the survey and had oil analysis done. Nothing untoward found.
Our first issue arose after just a few weeks and only a handful more hours on the generator. It was becoming increasingly lazy, taking several attempts to start until one day it simply went on strike. I checked everything, read the manual from start to finish, but could come up with no reason for its disobedience. It was in Corsica that we had it looked at by a mechanic, who reported that sea water had got into the block via the mis-fitted syphon/vacuum system. This had, it seems, been incorrectly fitted by the Neel yard, who had placed the syphon only a few inches above the water level, glued onto the side of the diesel tank. It should have been much higher, matching the one on the main engine which was fine. Several hours draining, refilling, running, then draining the oil again, another few hours relocating the syphon to a higher position on the front bulkhead, and we had a working generator. Hurrah.
Our joy was short-lived. After just two more weeks and 5 hours running, the same problem reoccurred. Back to then yard, who drained again, and set the syphon up properly this time. No charge. OK, we were back on track.
But it still had the odd hissy-fit when starting. Sometimes it was as good as gold, other times petulant and reluctant. There was no pattern to it, it just was being difficult. We had little faith in it, never knowing whether it would fire up or not. Filters and fluids were changed, and we managed another 40 hours on it before the major problem, and probably the scariest incident we have had to date on Skylark.
We were at anchor in Schengjin, Albania, having just picked up our friends Darren and Liesl who were joining us for the passage to Montenegro. It was a ferociously hot evening, so when we returned from dinner ashore I started the generator to run the aircon for an hour. The aircon will only operate with either shore power or the genset. The Yanmar started okay, for once, but stuck on the ‘start’ cycle rather than switch into running mode once the fancy electronic control system detected it had started correctly. The screen continued to read ‘start’, which meant the starter motor also remained engaged. Not good. 15 seconds and it would start to overheat. I rapidly pressed the stop button. Nothing. I tried every other button. Nothing. I tried the remote stop. Nothing. No response on any control panel. I cut the fuel line supply, but the run is several feet so it would take many minutes for the fuel in the line to be used. Too long. I took the front panel off to use the emergency stop lever, just like the main Volvo Penta engine has. No emergency stop lever. But I did notice a leaking raw water pump, which might explain the water in the bilge…… No time to worry about that now, I needed to stop this engine before we had a serious fire on our hands - every sailor’s nightmare scenario.
“The generator was stuck on the start cycle, and I had no control over it.”
By now the starter motor was melting and giving off acrid black smoke. I had a 115 decibel smoke alarm going off just above my head. Darren had grabbed two fire extinguishers, I had another next to the genes where it is always stowed. Desperately I switched every electrical connection to the generator off; the isolating switch, the main battery terminal, the main fuse. Nothing happened. I still had no way of stopping the runaway generator.
Then it stopped. I still don’t know exactly what caused it to stop, but mercifully it did. Relief flooded over us all. Smoke continued to belch from the starter motor for the next ten minutes as it cooled. We spent 30 minutes on deck to allow the worst of the smoke to clear. The yacht had an acrid, burning stench for the next 24 hours, and it took nearly a week for the smell to dissipate completely.
We found a Yanmar specialist in Montenegro a week later, who gallantly dismantled the generator and took the starter motor off. Sure enough, burnt to a crisp. They were unable to go any further, and did not want to take on a rebuild, so as I type we still have a generator in bits. We are no closer to understanding the electrical problem and what caused the machine to stick in the start cycle. They did not have a spare sea water pump, so that remains broken too.
Fixing the generator is now a winter job, assuming we can source the parts and find a competent mechanic near our winter berth. The unknown is the electrical system…. but I am not confident that it will be an easy fix.
Why no manual shut-off valve?
My biggest take away from the incident is the lack of an emergency fuel shut-off lever. The main VP engine has one, prominently marked in yellow, and I have checked it works. It does. Why a generator, essentially just a fixed-speed diesel engine with a big alternator, would not have some way of manually overriding the electrical control system strikes me as pure madness and a rather silly design omission. I will investigate how we can have a fuel shut-off valve fitted closer to the main block. I do not want to continue with a solely electronic control arrangement.
I have heard many folk say Yanmar are an unbreakable brand. That their engines will go on forever with the correct maintenance. That they are bullet-proof. Would I have another Yanmar engine? Absolutely not. If we could swap it out easily and for moderate cost I would, but as a new one from any reputable manufacturer will cost upwards of £12k plus fitting, it is not a decision we can justify.
Until we have another problem, perhaps……and given my confidence in the Yanmar, I suspect I will be writing again in the near future.
For an engine with less than 100 hours, serviced in accordance with
the manufacturer’s guidelines, it simply is not reliable enough.